Britain’s high-risk investors were not mostly beginners, FCA-based study found

UK adults investing in high-risk products were more likely to be seasoned participants than newcomers, according to a new TradingPlatforms.co.uk analysis of the FCA Financial Lives 2024 survey. The report found that 44% of cryptocurrency holders had first invested three or more years ago, while only 10% had less than one year of experience. Among CFD traders, the pattern was even more pronounced: 46% had been active for at least three years, compared with just 16% who had less than a year of experience.

That undermines a common assumption that the riskiest corners of retail finance are dominated mainly by inexperienced first-timers. TradingPlatforms.co.uk said the majority of people engaging with high-risk financial products often do so over extended periods rather than briefly dipping in and out. In both crypto and CFDs, the long-experience cohort comfortably outweighed the least experienced group, suggesting that many participants who stay in these markets do so despite already having had several years to understand the volatility and potential downside involved.

This pattern becomes more interesting when set against the report’s wider findings on participation. Overall appetite for high-risk products has fallen, with only 8.4% of investors choosing them, and only 4.3% of UK adults holding cryptocurrencies while 0.7% traded CFDs. In other words, the market for high-risk products appears small and shrinking, but the people who remain active in it are not predominantly novices. That gives the sector a very different profile from the stereotype of a constant wave of brand-new punters chasing quick wins.

The findings suggest that the UK’s high-risk investor base may be smaller than often assumed, but that many of those who participate are not newcomers. Within this group there is a sizeable number of investors with several years of experience in products such as cryptocurrencies and CFDs. That does not reduce the risks involved, but it indicates that some participants remain active in these markets over long periods rather than treating them as short-term experiments.

* * If no #mcl-market-ticker element exists, the widget inserts itself right * after this var sel = thisScript && thisScript.getAttribute("data-target"); if (sel) { var t = document.querySelector(sel); if (t) return t; } // 2) A dedicated mount element the host page provides. var el = document.getElementById(CONFIG.targetId); if (el) return el; // 3) Fallback: insert right after this script tag. el = document.createElement("div"); el.id = CONFIG.targetId; if (thisScript && thisScript.parentNode) { thisScript.parentNode.insertBefore(el, thisScript.nextSibling); } else { document.body.appendChild(el); } return el; } // ---- Data pipeline (identical logic to the standalone banner) ------------ function apiUrl(path) { if (!path) return path; if (/^https?:\/\//i.test(path)) return path; return CONFIG.apiBase + (path.charAt(0) === "/" ? "" : "/") + path; } function toNum(v) { var n = parseFloat(String(v == null ? "" : v).replace(/,/g, "")); return isFinite(n) ? n : null; } function fmtNum(v) { var n = parseFloat(String(v).replace(/,/g, "")); if (!isFinite(n)) return String(v == null ? "" : v); var d = Math.abs(n) >= 1 ? 2 : 4; return n.toLocaleString("en-US", { minimumFractionDigits: d, maximumFractionDigits: d }); } function changeClass(d) { if (d == null || Math.abs(d) < 1e-9) return "flat"; return d > 0 ? "up" : "down"; } function arrow(d) { if (d == null || Math.abs(d) < 1e-9) return "▬"; return d > 0 ? "▲" : "▼"; } async function fetchFiles(category, count) { var res = await fetch(apiUrl("/api/files?category=" + category)); if (!res.ok) throw new Error("list " + category + " " + res.status); var list = await res.json(); return Array.isArray(list) ? list.slice(0, count || 1) : []; } async function parseSheet(meta) { var res = await fetch(apiUrl(meta.url)); if (!res.ok) throw new Error("download " + res.status); var buf = await res.arrayBuffer(); var wb = XLSX.read(buf, { type: "array" }); return XLSX.utils.sheet_to_json(wb.Sheets[wb.SheetNames[0]], { defval: "" }); } function buildStocks(rows) { var items = []; rows.forEach(function (r) { var sym = r["Symbol"] || r["symbol"]; if (!sym) return; var close = toNum(r["Close"]); if (close == null) return; var prev = toNum(r["Prev Close"] || r["Previous Close"]); var delta = prev != null ? close - prev : null; var pct = (delta != null && prev) ? (delta / prev) * 100 : null; items.push({ sym: sym, val: fmtNum(close), delta: delta, pct: pct }); }); return items; } function buildForex(rows, prevRows) { var pmean = {}; (prevRows || []).forEach(function (r) { if (r["Currency"]) pmean[r["Currency"]] = toNum(r["Mean"]); }); var items = []; rows.forEach(function (r) { var cur = r["Currency"]; if (!cur) return; var mean = toNum(r["Mean"]), buy = toNum(r["Buying"]), sell = toNum(r["Selling"]); if (buy == null && sell == null && mean == null) return; var pv = pmean[cur]; var ref = mean != null ? mean : (buy != null && sell != null ? (buy + sell) / 2 : (buy != null ? buy : sell)); var delta = pv != null ? ref - pv : null; var pct = (delta != null && pv) ? (delta / pv) * 100 : null; items.push({ sym: cur, buy: buy != null ? fmtNum(buy) : "—", sell: sell != null ? fmtNum(sell) : "—", delta: delta, pct: pct }); }); var order = CONFIG.majorCurrencies; items.sort(function (a, b) { var ia = order.indexOf(a.sym), ib = order.indexOf(b.sym); if (ia === -1) ia = 999; if (ib === -1) ib = 999; if (ia !== ib) return ia - ib; return a.sym < b.sym ? -1 : 1; }); return items; } function chgHTML(it) { var cls = changeClass(it.delta); if (it.delta == null) return ''; var pctTxt = it.pct != null ? (it.pct >= 0 ? "+" : "") + it.pct.toFixed(2) + "%" : ""; return '' + arrow(it.delta) + " " + pctTxt + ""; } function stockHTML(it) { return '' + it.sym + '' + it.val + "" + chgHTML(it) + ""; } function forexHTML(it) { return '' + it.sym + "" + '' + CONFIG.labels.buy + ' ' + it.buy + ' · ' + CONFIG.labels.sell + ' ' + it.sell + "" + chgHTML(it) + ""; } function pill(t, k) { return '' + t + ""; } function render(track, stocks, forex, dateLabel) { if ((!stocks || !stocks.length) && (!forex || !forex.length)) { track.innerHTML = '
' + CONFIG.labels.unavailable + "
"; track.style.animation = "none"; return; } var parts = []; if (stocks && stocks.length) { parts.push(pill(CONFIG.labels.stocks)); stocks.forEach(function (s) { parts.push(stockHTML(s)); }); } if (forex && forex.length) { parts.push(pill(CONFIG.labels.forex, "forex")); forex.forEach(function (f) { parts.push(forexHTML(f)); }); } if (dateLabel) parts.push('' + CONFIG.labels.updated + ": " + dateLabel + ""); var content = parts.join(""); track.innerHTML = content + content; // duplicated for a seamless loop requestAnimationFrame(function () { var dur = Math.max(20, Math.round((track.scrollWidth / 2) / CONFIG.pxPerSecond)); track.style.animation = "none"; void track.offsetWidth; track.style.animation = "mcl-scroll " + dur + "s linear infinite"; }); } async function load(track) { try { var results = await Promise.allSettled([fetchFiles("hisa", 1), fetchFiles("fedha", 2)]); var stocks = [], forex = [], dateLabel = ""; if (results[0].status === "fulfilled" && results[0].value.length) { var hf = results[0].value[0]; dateLabel = hf.date || ""; stocks = buildStocks(await parseSheet(hf)); } if (results[1].status === "fulfilled" && results[1].value.length) { var ff = results[1].value; var curRows = await parseSheet(ff[0]); var prevRows = ff[1] ? await parseSheet(ff[1]) : []; forex = buildForex(curRows, prevRows); if (!dateLabel) dateLabel = ff[0].date || ""; } render(track, stocks, forex, dateLabel); } catch (e) { if (!track.querySelector(".mcl-item")) { track.innerHTML = '
' + CONFIG.labels.unavailable + "
"; track.style.animation = "none"; } } } function mountAndRun() { injectStyle(); var mount = getMount(); mount.innerHTML = '
' + '
' + CONFIG.brand + "" + '' + CONFIG.live + "
" + '
' + CONFIG.labels.unavailable + "
"; var track = mount.querySelector(".mcl-track"); function go() { load(track); setInterval(function () { load(track); }, CONFIG.refreshMs); } if (window.XLSX) { go(); return; } var sc = document.createElement("script"); sc.src = "https://cdnjs.cloudflare.com/ajax/libs/xlsx/0.18.5/xlsx.full.min.js"; sc.onload = go; sc.onerror = function () { track.innerHTML = '
' + CONFIG.labels.unavailable + "
"; }; (document.head || document.documentElement).appendChild(sc); } if (document.readyState === "loading") { document.addEventListener("DOMContentLoaded", mountAndRun); } else { mountAndRun(); } })();